Mr. and Mrs. Campbell Meath built the first home in Stagecoach Farms in 1958 on what is now known as Shady Oaks Drive. The contractor used a gas driven generator for power in as much as electricity was not available until the house was completed in May 1958. John Doaks built the second home in Stagecoach, also on Shady Oaks Drive. The third home was built by Bob and Clancy Kasper on Silver Spur (later purchased by Joe and Nevaire Richardson). Connor and Sue Webster built the fourth home in Stagecoach on Stagecoach Road. Connor Webster, who once served as the Judge for the City of Stagecoach, still lives in Stagecoach and he remains active in community affairs.
When the area was subdivided, two man-made lakes were excavated. Lake Hardin was excavated in 1958 and a three day rain filled it in. Lake Apache was under construction in 1961 when Hurricane Carla hit the Gulf Coast and the rain from the hurricane filled it in, ending all hope of further excavation.